CLE Leadership & Management
Ideas, Resources, and Techniques for CLE Professionals
A periodic e-newsletter

By Chuck Bingaman - chuck@chuckbingaman.com

#28 May 2006

Leadership    Since Proctor & Gamble’s CEO A.G. Lafley took over in 2000, annual sales have shot from $40 to $57 BILLION! A key approach he instituted was an annual all-day review for each product designed to set (or reset) its tone and direction. Lafley reviews all managers’ presentations in advance to weed out historical justifications and insists that the key questions for discussion are “where to play?” (defining markets) and “how to win?” (defining product and marketing strategies). If CLE organizations devoted similar, in-depth analyses to each product and product line, enhanced and productive focus would be inevitable. Jeffrey Pfeffer, writing in the April Business 2.0, quotes a study of corporate annual reports that found that stock prices were higher one year later when companies blamed poor performance on controllable internal factors rather than on external issues. “Attributing bad results to outside forces fuels…resignation,” says Pfeffer. “Coppng to shortcomings, on the other hand, is the first step to recovery. No one in a company is going to fix a problem until executives name and describe it. No one will follow a leader whose message is that success and failure depend on random factors. No one will take responsibility for his own errors unless he sees the company’s leaders building the foundation for a culture of truth-telling.”

Management    At least once each year review with all your employees the history of your CLE organization and CLE in general, tell them how it is governed, and walk them through a detailed financial update. Invite written questions in advance and take impromptu questions at the meeting. Such an update can give employees a sense of pride in their organization and an accurate picture of how it really works. Without periodic—and accurate—refreshers, CLE employees can miss the importance of what they do and develop highly inaccurate, even destructive, understandings of how the organization really works. If you create an outline of your organization’s history, you need simply update it yearly.   If you are now planning your budget for a July 1 fiscal year, be sure to plan funding for all needed employee training for the year. Ideally each employee will have a tailored and budgeted training plan. And any new software/hardware plans for the year need to be supported with training plans and funds. Periodically use a “secret shopper” to register for your CLE courses (by all the means you offer) and to order a publication, webcast, or other offering from your organization. Your “secret shopper” should be given a checklist of things to watch for and report to you on including whether his contact in your organization was friendly, polite, helpful, informed and efficient. Also, check the promptness of delivery of any items, the packaging and the condition they were in when delivered. Tell your staff in advance that you are using an outsider to sample your customer treatment and delivery times from a customer’s point of view.   Intergenerational conflicts are increasingly common in the CLE workplace with three and sometimes, for the first time in history, four generations working together. With their widely differing values and priorities, it is vital that you understand their approaches to life and work. For a quick cheat-sheet summarizing generational differences, see http://www.library.dal.ca/law/St-Johns/Pres/Tues17/Hartnett-Generational_Differences.pdf.

Resources    See www.workforce.com for a range of resources on handling personnel problems, job descriptions, performance evaluations, etc.    Check out www.inter-alia.net, Tom Mighell’s outstanding blawg on legal research, both for his useful content and as a great example of what a stellar blawg can be. Another VERY good blawg is http://jimcalloway.typepad.com written by Oklahoma State Bar Technology Advisor Jim Calloway.   The New PR Toolkit: Strategies for Successful Media Relations by Deirdre Breakenridge and Thomas J. DeLoughry (Prentice Hall, 2003) offers a valuable 21st century guide to effective media success, an area where CLE organizations are traditionally weak.   For an engrossing read as well as a comprehensive course in leadership, human relations, emotional intelligence and a few other vital human skills, I heartily recommend Doris Kearns Goodwin’s A Team of Rivals (Simon & Schuster, 2005). It’s the story of how Abraham Lincoln recruited a group of political leaders, several of whom had been his bitterest rivals and detractors, into his cabinet, drew their best work from them in a time of national crisis, and gained their personal support and admiration in the process. Terrific stuff!

Please keep in touch!  CCB


Following 20 years as Executive Director of a major American CLE organization, Chuck now consults and teaches on strategic planning, marketing, CLE executive hiring, and management challenges with CLE and other legal organizations, law firms, law schools and others. He also offers economical in-house training through conference call courses for CLE and bar association staffs. He welcomes your inquiries on projects designed to enhance your organization’s effectiveness.

You can contact him at chuck@chuckbingaman.com, at 1-603-756-9268, or at P.O. Box 390, Walpole, NH, USA 03068-0390. Past issues of this newsletter are archived at www.chuckbingaman.com.